Real Options Theory Meets AI-Enabled R&D

The Hidden Value of
Exploring in Parallel

AI slashes prototype costs by 90% and compresses weeks into minutes. When trying is nearly free, the winning move is to try more. This calculator shows exactly how much that's worth.

Try the Calculator
START Try 1 FAIL Try 2 FAIL Try 3 SUCCESS Try 4 FAIL Try 5 FAIL
01

The Problem with Traditional Development

Premature Commitment

Traditional development forces you to pick one approach early and invest heavily before you know if it's right. By the time you discover it's wrong, you've already spent the budget.

The Cost of Being Wrong

In software, the cost of a wrong architectural decision compounds over time. What starts as a 2-week detour becomes a 6-month rewrite. Teams learn to avoid risk entirely.

Ideas Left on the Table

When exploration is expensive, organizations become conservative. Moonshot ideas get killed in planning. The unconventional approach never gets tried. Most good ideas die before they're tested.

02

Real Options: A Better Mental Model

In finance, an option is the right — but not the obligation — to make a decision later, when you have more information. Real Options Theory, pioneered by economists Stewart Myers, Avinash Dixit, and Robert Pindyck, extends this to business decisions.

When you explore multiple approaches in parallel, you're buying options. You invest a small amount upfront to preserve the ability to choose the best path later — or abandon entirely if none work out.

The key insight: Expanded NPV = Static NPV + Option Value. Even if a project's expected value looks marginal, the flexibility to expand on success or abandon on failure has measurable economic worth.

Probability of At Least One Success

P(≥1) = 1 − (1−p)N
p Success rate per approach
N Number of parallel attempts
P(≥1) Probability at least one succeeds
E[V] P(≥1) × V − N × C

Types of Real Options

Option to Defer

Wait for more information before committing. Valuable when uncertainty is high and the opportunity won't disappear.

Option to Expand

Scale up if initial results are promising. A small pilot buys you the right to a larger investment.

Option to Abandon

Cut losses early. The ability to walk away limits downside and makes bold experiments rational.

Staged Investment

Break projects into phases. Each stage is an option to continue or stop based on what you learn.

"The value of information is highest when the cost of gathering it is lowest. AI has made exploration cheap — so explore more."
03

AI Changes the Economics

Before AI

  • Each prototype costs weeks and tens of thousands
  • Parallel paths require parallel teams
  • Moonshots die in planning meetings
  • You pick one approach and commit early
Result: Forced bets under uncertainty

With AI

  • Iteration speed improves 75–90% with agentic workflows
  • Prototype costs drop ~90% (minutes instead of weeks)
  • One small team explores many paths in parallel
  • Moonshots become economically rational to test
Result: More options, better decisions

The Math of More Attempts

75–90% Faster iteration speed in early-stage prototyping
67% Success probability with 5 tries at 20% each
8×+ Expected value improvement when costs collapse
04

Calculate Your Option Value

Model your scenario below. The calculator computes P(≥1) = 1 − (1−p)N to show how parallel attempts shift the probability of success — and the expected value of exploration.

60% failure rate per approach
3 parallel approaches
$2,000 per approach
$200,000 potential value
Option Value Added (ΔE) $52,800 E[NetN] − E[Net1]
Single Attempt EV $78,000 p × V − C
Parallel EV $130,800 P(≥1) × V − N × C
P(≥1 Success) 93.6% 1 − (1−p)N
ROI on Extra Attempts 880% ΔE / (N−1)C
05

Examples of Theory Application

Software Feature

Feature Development with AI

Traditional: 20% success rate, $1M payoff, $200K per prototype. Expected value = 0.2 × $1M − $200K = $0 (breakeven).

With AI: Cost drops ~90% to $20K. Same $200K budget = 10 parallel trials. P(≥1) = 1 − 0.8¹⁰ = 89%.

10 parallel trials
89% success probability
$690K expected value gain
From breakeven to +$690K option value
Startup Strategy

Product Concept Validation

Setup: 10% chance each concept resonates with customers. $10M market value if one hits.

Traditional (2 concepts @ $100K): P(≥1) = 19%, EV = $1.7M.

AI-enabled (10 concepts @ $20K): P(≥1) = 65%, EV = $6.3M.

10 concepts tested
65% success probability
3.7× improvement in EV
Same budget, 3.7× the expected value
Moonshot

When to Take the Long Shot

Traditionally, "moonshots" with 5% success rates were dismissed — the cost of failure was too high to justify attempting.

With AI, if a prototype costs $250K and the payoff is $50M, the expected value is 0.05 × $50M − $250K = $2.25M. Worth taking.

5% success rate
$250K cost to try
$2.25M positive EV
Low odds, but the payoff justifies the attempt
06

Academic Foundations

This framework is grounded in Nobel Prize-winning economics. Real options analysis emerged from Black-Scholes option pricing and has been applied to value flexibility in oil exploration, pharmaceutical R&D, and technology strategy for over 40 years.

Dixit, A. K., & Pindyck, R. S. (1994) Investment Under Uncertainty Princeton University Press — The foundational text on real options and irreversible investment decisions
Myers, S. C. (1977) Determinants of Corporate Borrowing Journal of Financial Economics, 5(2), 147-175 — Introduced the concept of "growth options" in R&D
Black, F., & Scholes, M. (1973) The Pricing of Options and Corporate Liabilities Journal of Political Economy, 81(3), 637-654 — Nobel Prize-winning options pricing framework
Trigeorgis, L. (1996) Real Options: Managerial Flexibility and Strategy in Resource Allocation MIT Press — Comprehensive guide to applying real options in strategic planning
Luehrman, T. A. (1998) Investment Opportunities as Real Options: Getting Started on the Numbers Harvard Business Review — Practical introduction to valuing real options in business
Put this into practice

We help teams find the right problems, map the solution space, and validate fast.

We partner with leaders who want to turn real options theory into a working innovation engine. Our process speeds up problem identification and clarification, expands the solution space, and rapidly validates approaches with AI-assisted prototyping. The gains are massive because iteration is now measured in minutes, not weeks.

Reach out for a working session We’ll map your option portfolio and quantify where to explore next.